QRP T-tuner for $16 / €12 ?!?!

As I’m planning some short holiday /P sessions, I’ve ordered 24x 6000 mA (yeah right!) NiMH batteries, a 10W solar panel and an MPPT solar charge controller for my FT-897D on eBay (from China). This evening I was browsing eBay for a second hand QRP tuner and to my great surprised, I saw an auction for a QRP T-circuit tuner kit from Hong Kong China for only $16 with free shipping worldwide option. Incredible! I just couldn’t resist, this is the one I got: www.ebay.com/itm/271357343348.

It’s a typical T-circuit tuner with a 12 position inductor to ground and input / output capacitors. Bonus is a nice SWR dipper tuning aid circuit that helps you tune (LED lights up when SWR is high and dims when SWR is low). I think the circuit is very similar to a product that sells on eBay (also from Hong Kong) for $79.50!! >> www.ebay.com/itm/221204948808

The kit I bought uses a coil wound on a T106-2 toroid, good for around 17.5 uH. The “expensive” ready-made version’s circuit is indicating the bigger T130-2 toroid that has (?!) a lower Al value so only has 14.5 uH with 36 turns. Also, the SWR dipper circuit is slightly different. The transformer for this circuit is wound on a FT37-43 toroid, but my kit has a 2:5 (1:2.5) turn ratio whilst the “commercial” version has 5:20 (1:4). Will try the kit’s circuit, if it doesn’t work, I will experiment with the “commercial” version’s circuit.

I will keep you posted on the kit building progress and the results! Here are some pictures of the kit:

The PCB with “SWR dipper circuit”:qrp tuner kit 05

All the parts:qrp tuner kit 04

The built product:qrp tuner kit 03

The circuit:qrp tuner kit 02

Here are some pictures of the $79.50 “commercial version” of a similar tuner:

qrp tuner kit 07

qrp tuner kit 06

UPC unique wire tuner

About a week ago, I saw this “UPC Unique wire tuner” on tweedehands.nl, a Dutch equivalent of ebay.com. As I’m very much into end-fed antennes because they seem to work well and are very easy to erect or span away, I decided to buy the good old 70’s made in USA L/C tuner. And what a pretty tuner it is, look for yourself:IF

It has one variable C with big plates and a plate distance of 1+ mm, probably around 250 – 350 pF…IF

and one huge roller inductor that seems to be of very good quality, probably around 25 to 35 uH. The roller inductor has a nifty two digit counter and on the inductor dial knob there’s also a 1-10 indication which allows for very precise registration of settings.

IF
All the parts seem to be of very good quality and also craftmanship is very neat. The circuit is a typical L/C circuit. The tuner comes with handy plugs to short out one of the PL connectors to ground. At first I was a bit confused, but of course this lets you choose if you want the inductor in series and capacitor to ground (that’s what I’m familiar with and tend to call “LC configuration”) or vice versa (“CL configuration). According to PA0FRI this methode as similar but requires a little less capacitance so if a wire is tuned with full capacitance but that’s still not sufficient, the CL configuration might come in handy.

I did some testing in my backyard. I used a 7m stack on fishing pole with some length of wire that I once used for a 40m end-fed experiment. Our 1 week “autumn holiday” has just started and I had to take advantage of the nice weather:

IF
As I can recall, the total wire length I used is around 14m of which 7m is coiled up somewhere in the middle on a 50mm PVC pipe (not visible in the picture). As a counterpoise, I used a random (I think around 8m) of speaker wire that I used for some kind of 40m holiday groundplane once. I connected the tuner input to my RigExpert AA-54 (7.1 MHz), set the capacitor to about 1/3 capacity and started turning the inductor dial looking for an SWR dip. When found, I increased capacity to see if I could get the SWR further down. If that was not the case, I decreased capacity and turned inductor to minimum SWR and so on. It turned out I could tune the L/C circuit to resonance on 80m, 40m, 20m, 15m and 10m easily. Once tuned, the Rx was (very close) to 0 which kind of confirms my understanding of this “tuned circuit”. Even though the wire is not resonant, the tuner makes up for the extra or missing wire and as a whole, it is a resonant circuit. Pretty cool!

Here’s some proof; an LCR graph of the wire tuned to 40m:
UPC40m RCL
As you can see in the graph, the Rx = 0 somewhere around 7.120 MHz. And the impedance (Z) equals the resistance (R) meaning there is no imaginary resistance meaning the “system” is in resonance. I was surprised by the bandwidth by the way. Look at the SWR graph:
UPC40m SWR close-up
As you can see over the whole band, the SWR is better than 1:1:3 !! Probably because the wire I used was near a half a wave on 40m, so the wire itself was close to resonance as well (??? not sure about this ???). On 80m it seems to tune OK as well, look a the graphs below:
UPC80m RCL
UPC80m SWR
Again the R(esistance) equals the impedance (Z) on 3.7 MHz meaning the Rx = 0 and system is in resonance. Note that the bandwidth is much much narrower, only around 70 kHz for an SWR better than 1:2. Still, for /P use it’s nice to be able to tune a length of wire to resonance (it is resonant, not just 50 Ohms!). Same story on 20m:
UPC20m RCL
UPC20m SWR
Bandwidth is slightly better, a little over 100 kHz for an SWR better than 1:2 which is acceptable for /P use I guess. I got similar results on 15m and 10m. Bandwidth on 10m was better, very low SWR over full 1 MHz spectrum. Not sure why it’s so narrow on 20m, maybe somebody out there knows the answer to this question? Oh, of course I realise these measurements do not tell anything about the performance in practice, but I will be doing some tests coming week (if the weather OK) so will follow up this article.

On the previous pictures you probably noticed the fixed “door knob” capacitors on the back. As I’m no tuner elmer, it took me a little reasoning before I figured out what it did and how it worked. I actually raised the question on a local 80m QSO and while I was describing the circuit, I realised the extra capacitors could convert the L/C circuit (in C/L configuration) into a T-circuit with fixed output capacitors. Check the backside:
IF
As you can see, on the input side (lower right), I’ve connected the counterpoise wire. The PL connector is the input of the system (that’s where I had the analyser connector). This input is connected to the variable capacitor, so currently the capacitor is in series with the input and I configured for a C/L circuit. The PL connector on the left side is shorted to ground with a neat jumper. The wire (ceramic insulator) is connected in between the capacitor and inductor making a typical C/L circuit.

Now note the extra jumpers in the middle top. Currently, these are shorting out the door knob capacitors but when one, two or both are set horizontally, you add capacitance to the output (before the wire). If the system is configured with C in series and L to ground, you add capacitance to the output making it a traditional T-circuit. The capacitance is fixed of course. I have figured out how to set the jumpers. Considering the fact they are 4 logical bits (on/off, true/false, 0/1); 2 bits with jumpers horizontally and 2 bits with jumpers vertically, I would have expected 8 combinations. Later I realised that “all off” is the same combination vertically as well as horizontally so 1 combination less leaving 7 combinations. With some reasoning I found only 4 settings:

both jumpers on (horizontally OR vertically): no output capacitance
lower jumper horizontally: no output capacitance
top jumper horizontally: 70 pF (2 door knobs in parallel in series with 1 door knob)
right jumper vertically: 100 pF (bypasses the two door knobs in parallel)
left jumper vertically: 200 pF (bypasses the single door knob)

Not sure when to use the T-circuit (probably when L-circuit cannot match the wire?), will found in practice I guess.

L-tuner blijkt ook T-tuner HI

Nou, de UPC unique wire tuner is binnen, wat een PRACHTIG ding. Ga ‘m volgende week eens proberen. We gaan met de caravan nog een midweekje weg. Het weer wordt niet geweldig, maar ik hoop dat het in ieder geval een beetje droog is. Deze tuner is bedoeld om rechtstreeks een antennedraad aan vast te maken, met het L/C circuit kun je ahw verschillende mono band end-fed aanpassingen maken (dat is immers ook een L/C circuit maar dan met vaste spoel en capaciteit). Het zal niet zo druk zijn op de camping, dus ik neem een kilometer draad mee, die stop ik in mijn 10m GFK hengeltje en vanaf de top van dat hengeltje trek ik de draad wel ergens een boom in. Bedoeling is om een meter of 17 te gaan spannen en dan eens kijken of ik dat aan de praat krijg op 40m. Er is wel veel storing op het lichtnet van de camping, maargoed, het gaat even om het experimentje. De tuner zet ik in een plastic bak onder de caravan vlak bij het mastje waar de draad in gaat.

Op de foto’s die ik eerder publiceerde, was te zien dat er ook nog twee door knob condensators inzaten. Ik dacht dat dat een modificatie was b.v. om wat extra capaciteit parallel bij te schakelen, maar het is ingenieuzer dan ik dacht. In mijn tuner zitten drie door knobs, volgens mij van 100 pF elk. Ik kan met twee handig stekkertjes één, of twee parallel of alle drie de deurknoppen inschakelen. Die worden bijgeschakeld tussen de variabele C en de rolspoel. In het begin begreep ik het niet zo goed, maar toen ik vanavond mijn vraag stelde op 80m (o.a. met PA3CRS) kon ik ‘m eigenlijk zelf beantwoorden. Je kunt nl. dmv stekkertjes ook kiezen of je na de ingang de rolspoel krijgt en dan de variabele C naar massa of vice versa. Zo ben ik het gewend van de mono band end fed aanpassing maar het stekkertje zat andersom; dus eerst de variabele C en dan de rolspoel naar massa. Wanneer je in het midden een van die L/C kring een vaste C zet, heb je dus eigenlijk een T-circuit waarvan de uitgang niet instelbaar is. Zo heb ik mijn Ameritron tuner bij voorkeur ook ingesteld; de uitgangs C op maximale capaciteit, dat schijnt de hoogste efficiency te geven (zie ook het ARRL artikel “Getting the most out of your t-network antenna tuner” (http://www.arrl.org/files/file/Technology/tis/info/pdf/9501046.pdf). Een hele slimme “fabrieks modificatie”; op deze manier heb je dus een L/C tuner, maar ook een T-tuner (met vaste uitgangscapaciteit). Ik moet me nog even verdiepen in de voor- en nadelen van beide types, maar ik weet dat Frits PA0FRI daar het één en ander over geschreven heeft, dus dat gaan we eens even rustig bekijken. Wordt vervolgd.

UPC unique wire tuner

In the past I’ve made some attempts to homebrew a simple L-tuner circuit that I wanted to use to tune random (actually “convenient”) lengths of wire to a certain frequency. The idea of course was to be able to find the ideal L/C ratio to tune a holiday vertical (wire in a fishing pole) to my favorite 40m band.

On a ham fest, I bought a small (10 uH?) roller inductor and I had a 250 pF variable capacitor with sufficient plate distance lying around the shack. I soldered ‘m in series and did some tests with random lengths of wire but I never actually took this “solution” into productie. So for my holidays, I used my double coil holiday end-fed; about 8m of wire with two coils; a 15 uH coil acting as 10m trap and loading coil for 20m + 40m and a 30 uH coil acting as a 20m trap and loading coil for 40m. This antenne worked fine on 20m and probably great on 10m, but the efficiency on 40m was very limited.

This autumn, we will have a short holiday with our caravan and I want to test a “random” length of wire inside my 10m fiber glass mast, tuned by a decent LC circuit. To my surprise, I saw a UPC unique wire tuner (USA 70’s) for sale. Price was fair so I contacted the seller and bought it. I hoping it to arrive somewhere this week. Basically, this is an L/C. circuit with inductor first, than vcapacitor to ground. It’s from the 70’s, made from good quality parts and built like a tank. It’s not possible to switch the vcapacitor before or after the inductor so it will only tune high impedances. While 10m of wire will provide low impedance to the tuner, I’m planning on having a 10 – 20 uH loading coil in the center (like mobile whips do) so that the physical length will be around 14m. This will provide a relatively high impedance on 20m, 40m and 80m so the L/C circuit should be able to tune it down to 50 Ohms. I’m really curious what the results will be, I will keep you informed. Some pictures from the internet:

upc01

 

 

TK: Palstar AT-500 1.8-54 MHz 600W EUR325

Palstar AT-500 openlijn/coax tuner 1.8-54 MHz 600W. T-match circuit met een rolspoel en één dubbele (differential) afstem C. Bediening met slechts twee knoppen, daardoor makkelijker en sneller af te stemmen dan bovendien compacter van formaat. Aansluiting voor 2 coaxkabels én een gebalanceerde voedingslijn, ingebouwde 1:4 stroombalun, kruisnaald meter met gelijktijdige weergave van forwarded power, reflected power én SWR. AVG of peak meting met “hold” functie.

Topkwaliteit, hand made in USA. Door de hoge Q is dip vrij scherp (itt bij MFJ tuners), logisch en juist een goed teken: hoge Q en dat betekent lage verliezen! Te gebruiken met 500W CW/RTTY of 600W PEP. Oerdegelijke en perfect werkend, verkeert in nieuwstaat, er zit werkelijk geen krasje op. Nieuwprijs is EUR499, vaste verkoopprijs EUR325. Tuner wordt NIET verstuurd, uitsluitend afhalen in Druten na demonstratie.

TK: Yaesu FC-707 tuner (VERKOCHT)

Ik heb besloten om de Daiwa CNW-520 tuner zelf te houden. Ik heb naast mijn Palstar AT-500 ook nog een LDG AT-200Pro en drie tuners is wel genoeg HI. Daarom heb ik mijn Yaesu FC-707 tuner te koop aangeboden, tot voor kort mijn trouwe vakantiegenoot HI. Inmiddels verkocht.

Oerdegelijke 150W T-tuner met twee variabele C’s en één spoel met aftakkingen (voor lage banden wordt een extra spoel op ringkern bijgeschakeld). Mooi en degelijk gebouwd met goede componenten.

Bruikbaar van 80 t/m 10m incl. WARC banden, tuned volgens de specificaties 10 – 250 Ohm (SWR tot 1:5) dus beter dan de meeste ingebouwde tuners. In de praktijk tuned dit apparaatje vrijwel alles dat ik er aan hang. Heeft een 15W en 150W stand en een ingebouwde dummyload. Meter geeft SWR of REF/FWD (schakelbaar) power weer. Voor gebruik van de dummyload is een spanning van 8V vereist. In de shack gebruikte ik gewoon 12V en daar heeft hij het altijd goed op gedaan.